Change Elements

Make Change Matter. Make Change Happen.

Journal

Change Elements provides services that help individuals, leaders and teams to successfully navigate through change.

Decoding Resistance to Change: Why do Employees Push Back?

by

Resistance to change occurs when the psychological contract between the employer and the employee breaks

“People don’t resist change. They resist being changed” says Peter Senge in his widely known book on learning organizations. This perspective resonates with our understanding or resistance in organizations as well. Let’s try to first understand resistance to change through the lens of psychology.

What is Change Resistance?

Resistance to change is a natural and anticipated phenomenon in the workplace that can hinder the successful implementation of new initiatives, regardless of their scale or rationale. Employees may exhibit various cues and behaviors that indicate their reluctance to adapt to new circumstances. These signs of resistance can manifest in passive or active forms of opposition, such as decreased productivity, increased absenteeism, negative attitudes, and complaints. Non-verbal indicators like reduced eye contact and body language displaying disinterest or discomfort during discussions about change efforts can provide valuable insights into employee resistance.

One key factor underlying resistance to change is the psychological contract, which refers to the perceptions of mutual obligations between employees and employers. While not explicitly defined in formal employment contracts, the psychological contract is built upon unspoken assumptions and expectations developed through verbal promises and past actions. When changes disrupt established ways of working, they can threaten the positive psychological contract, resulting in a loss of commitment, engagement, and job satisfaction.

How to Overcome Resistance to Change?

Overcoming resistance to change requires a proactive and strategic approach. Managers and leaders play a vital role in guiding employees through the change process and fostering a positive environment.

To effectively manage resistance to change, it is crucial for managers to closely observe employee behavior and communication patterns. This observation should take place at both the individual and team levels. Managers should be attuned to cues of resistance and be proactive in addressing them. Regular feedback sessions and group meetings, provide opportunities for employees to voice their concerns and contribute to the change process. By actively involving employees and considering their input, managers can foster a sense of ownership and reduce resistance.

In addition to direct observation and feedback, monitoring metrics such as staff turnover rates and employee satisfaction levels can provide valuable insights into the acceptance and impact of change. By comparing these metrics before and after implementing changes, managers can assess the effectiveness of their change management strategies and make adjustments as needed.

To mitigate threats to the psychological contract during change, open and honest communication is vital. Employees should be informed about the change as early as possible, allowing them time to process and understand the reasons behind it. Building multiple channels for feedback and involvement helps employees feel heard and valued. However, it is essential to manage expectations by being realistic about the impacts of the change and addressing any potential disadvantages. This transparency and honesty create a foundation of trust and reduce uncertainty among employees.

Changes that may involve redundancies require extra care and planning. In these cases, involving the Human Resources department from the early stages of planning is crucial. HR professionals can provide guidance on effective communication strategies and help address staff concerns and issues. If the organization has a staff consultation group or is unionized, engaging with these stakeholders from the beginning is essential for fostering collaboration and obtaining their valuable input.

Successful change implementation requires not only addressing resistance but also helping employees recognize the potential benefits and opportunities for personal growth that come with change. Often, resistance arises from a fear of job insecurity or a perceived threat to one’s role. By effectively communicating the positive aspects of change, such as increased efficiency or improved work-life balance, managers can help employees overcome their resistance and embrace the change.

Effective strategies to address and overcome resistance:

To summarize, by implementing these strategies and fostering a supportive and inclusive environment, organizations can overcome resistance to change and achieve successful outcomes.

  1. Open and Transparent Communication: Communicate openly and honestly about the change as early as possible. Provide clear explanations regarding the reasons behind the change and the expected benefits. Address concerns and uncertainties proactively to reduce resistance.
  2. Employee Involvement: Create opportunities for employees to give feedback, share their perspectives, and actively participate in the change process. This involvement helps employees feel valued, builds trust, and increases their commitment to the proposed changes.
  3. Management of Expectations: Be realistic about the impacts of the change and avoid overselling the benefits. Acknowledge and address any potential disadvantages or challenges that employees may face. By managing expectations and being honest about both the positive and negative aspects of the change, you can foster a sense of trust and credibility.
  4. Support and Training: Provide the necessary support, resources, and training to help employees adapt to the change. Equip them with the skills and knowledge required to embrace and navigate the new circumstances effectively. This support can help alleviate fears and build confidence in managing the change.
  5. Leadership Role Modeling: Leaders should lead by example and actively demonstrate their commitment to the change. When employees see their leaders embracing the change, it encourages them to follow suit. Leadership support and involvement are crucial in creating a positive change culture.
  6. Recognition and Celebration of  Progress: Acknowledge and celebrate milestones and successes throughout the change journey. Recognizing the efforts and accomplishments of employees helps maintain motivation and reinforces the benefits of change.

In conclusion, resistance to change is a natural response that can arise in the workplace during the implementation of new change initiatives. Understanding the signs of resistance and addressing them through effective strategies can help organizations navigate change more effectively. By prioritizing open communication, employee involvement, managing expectations, providing support, demonstrating leadership, and celebrating progress, organizations can overcome resistance and create a positive change culture that leads to successful outcomes.

7 Key Principles for Effective Stakeholder Engagement in Change Management

by

7 Key Principles of Shareholder Engagement in Change Management
Stakeholder engagement is pivotal in driving effective change.

“Stakeholder engagement is pivotal to the whole process of effective change. It is the essence of leading through influence.”

Patrick Mayfield

In today’s rapidly evolving business landscape, successful change management requires more than just focusing on tasks and processes. It necessitates the active engagement of stakeholders at every step. In this article, we explore the framework presented by Patrick Mayfield, which emphasizes the importance of stakeholder engagement in driving effective change. By understanding the principles of stakeholder engagement and their practical application, change managers can navigate the complexities of change with greater success.

I. The Power of Stakeholder Engagement in Change Management

A. Leading Through Influence

To truly lead change, it is crucial to recognize that influence extends far beyond authority. By understanding stakeholders, prioritizing their needs, and mobilizing their support, change managers can create and sustain the momentum required for successful transformation. For example, by involving key stakeholders in decision-making processes, a change manager demonstrates a commitment to inclusivity and gains valuable insights that contribute to informed decision-making.

B. Recognizing the Importance of Engaging People

Humans are inherently social beings, finding meaning and purpose through connections and relationships. Research has shown that change managers who invest time and effort in engaging with stakeholders achieve better results than those solely focused on technical and process aspects. For instance, by actively seeking input and feedback from employees, a change manager fosters a sense of ownership and empowerment, driving greater commitment and collaboration.

C. The Pull of People Engagement in Change Management

Engaging with stakeholders goes beyond a mechanical process of change. It forms the very fabric that contextualizes and frames change management initiatives. Without meaningful engagement, change efforts lack the necessary traction for long-term success. Consider a scenario where a change manager fails to communicate the benefits and rationale behind a proposed change to key stakeholders. In such cases, resistance and misunderstanding can hinder progress, resulting in suboptimal outcomes.

II. The Role of Relationships in Change Management

Change managers who allocate discretionary time to engage with stakeholders demonstrate a leaning toward people, building stronger relationships and promoting buy-in. They recognize the significance of nurturing these relationships to enable effective change. For example, by fostering open channels of communication and building trust among stakeholders, a change manager encourages collaboration and knowledge-sharing, ultimately enhancing the success of the change effort.

Moreover, change managers who take calculated risks, observe responses, and adapt their strategies exhibit a leaning toward action, ensuring the change journey remains dynamic and responsive to evolving circumstances.

For this to happen, change managers must adopt a progressive view of engagement, treating people as unique individuals with their own motivations, emotions, and concerns. By embracing conversations and genuinely listening to stakeholders, change managers tap into a wealth of ideas and perspectives. For instance, by conducting focus groups or surveys to understand the concerns and expectations of stakeholders, a change manager can tailor change initiatives to address specific needs, ensuring higher levels of engagement and support.

III. The Seven Principles of Stakeholder Engagement

According to Patrick Mayfield, there are 7 principles for successful stakeholder engagement.

Principle 1: You can forget important stakeholders, but they won’t forget you

By acknowledging the significance of all stakeholders, even those who might be overlooked, change managers can avoid potential resistance and negative impacts. For example, a change manager leading an IT system implementation should remember to involve end-users and gather their feedback, ensuring the system aligns with their needs and minimizing resistance to change.

Principle 2: Shareholder identification is a continuous practice

Change is a dynamic process, and new stakeholders may emerge while others fade away. Regularly reviewing and reassessing stakeholder identification allows change managers to maintain effective engagement strategies throughout the change journey. For instance, a change manager leading a company-wide rebranding effort should continuously identify new stakeholders, such as external partners or customers, to ensure their perspectives are considered during the change process.

Principle 3: Prioritizing and segmenting stakeholders is a moment in time

Prioritizing stakeholders based on their influence and impact is crucial for effective resource allocation and communication strategies. Change managers should regularly re-evaluate stakeholder priorities to ensure alignment with evolving project needs. For instance, during a product development process, a change manager may identify a change in customer preferences, prompting a shift in priority from internal stakeholders to external customers.

Principle 4: Some stakeholders are best engaged by others

Change managers should recognize that they may not always be the best person to engage certain stakeholders. Identifying influential individuals or groups within the stakeholder network and leveraging their relationships can enhance engagement outcomes. For example, a change manager implementing a sustainability initiative may engage influential employees who are passionate about environmental issues to champion the cause within their respective departments.

Principle 5: Seek first to understand, then be understood

Active listening and empathetic communication are vital in stakeholder engagement. By genuinely understanding stakeholder perspectives and concerns, change managers can tailor their communication to address specific needs effectively. For instance, a change manager introducing a new remote work policy should conduct focus groups to understand employees’ concerns and provide clear, empathetic explanations about how the policy benefits both the company and individual employees.

Principle 6: Emotion trumps reason

Emotions play a significant role in stakeholder engagement. Change managers should acknowledge and address emotional responses to change, as they can greatly influence stakeholders’ attitudes and behaviors. For instance, during a merger or acquisition, change managers should anticipate and address employees’ fears and anxieties, providing reassurance and support throughout the process.

Principle 7: Demonstration trumps argument

Actions speak louder than words in stakeholder engagement. Change managers should actively demonstrate the benefits and value of the change through tangible results, inspiring stakeholders to become advocates for the change. For example, a change manager implementing a new customer service approach should share success stories that highlight improved customer satisfaction and increased loyalty, thereby reinforcing the positive impact of the change.

A Journey Towards a Pro-Change Organization

Effective change management requires a comprehensive approach that acknowledges the power of stakeholder engagement. By understanding the principles of stakeholder engagement and applying them throughout the change process, change managers can cultivate meaningful relationships, drive collaboration, and ensure successful outcomes. By prioritizing people and leveraging relationships, change managers can navigate the complexities of change with confidence, inspiring stakeholders to embrace the journey towards a pro-change organization.

Leading Change: Top 5 Change Management Skills for Successful Managers

by

Change managers or change agents, who are responsible for guiding organizations through transitions, must possess leadership, communication, problem-solving, emotional intelligence and adaptability to be successful
Navigating Change: A Comprehensive Guide to the Top 5 Skills for Change Management Success

Change management is a complex process that involves a range of skills to achieve success. Those in the role of change managers or change agents are tasked with guiding organizations through periods of change. To effectively fulfill this responsibility, all change practitioners require more than just a smart change management strategy or a deep understanding of change management methodologies; they also need a distinct skill set that empowers them to tackle the myriad challenges that surface throughout the change management process.

Mastering Change: Develop Change Management Skills

In the dynamic landscape of today’s business world, the role of a change manager has never been more crucial. Organizations constantly strive to adapt and evolve, and effective change management is the linchpin that ensures these transitions are successful. Whether you’re embarking on a career in change management or looking to enhance your existing skill set, understanding and developing key change management skills is essential in managing change.

Top Change Management Skills for the Change Practitioner

As organizations constantly seek to adapt, innovate, and grow, the effective management of any organizational change becomes paramount. To successfully lead change, every change management practitioner needs to inspire, effectively communicate, address challenges, build trust and be ready to adapt their change management strategies and initiatives rapidly if needed.

Inspirational Leadership

Change managers must possess strong leadership skills to guide their organizations through the change process. They need to be able to inspire and motivate employees to embrace the change and take ownership of it for successful change management. A strong leader can help to create a sense of urgency, provide a clear vision of the desired outcome, and build a coalition of support.

For example, when Procter & Gamble (P&G) went through a major restructuring process followed by an organizational change in the late 2000s, the company’s CEO, A.G. Lafley, played a crucial role in leading the change. He clearly communicated the reasons for the change and the benefits it would bring, and he worked to build buy-in and support from employees. Through his leadership, P&G was able to successfully implement the transformational change initiative and emerge as a stronger and more competitive company.

Effective leadership in change management also involves understanding and addressing resistance to change from employees. A strong change management leader should be able to understand the reasons for resistance, and work on addressing the underlying concerns, by for example involving employees in the change process, providing clear communication, creating a sense of security during the process and ensuring adequate support.

Two-Way Communication with Employees

Change managers must be able to effectively communicate the change to all stakeholders, including employees, customers, and shareholders. They must be able to clearly and persuasively explain the change management strategy, the change management process and the change initiatives. Managing change requires that all parties are on board with the reasons behind the change, what the change will involve, and how it will benefit the organization.

For example, when Netflix decided to shift its focus from renting DVDs to streaming video, they had to clearly communicate this transformational change to their customers. As this is a major change, they created comprehensive change programs with a solid communication plan, which included detailed explanations of the benefits of streaming, such as instant access to a wide variety of content, and they worked to address any concerns that customers had about the change. This helped to minimize customer churn and build support for the new service.

Effective communication also involves building a transparent and regular dialogue with employees, and involving them in the decision-making process. By doing so, employees will feel that their opinions and concerns are heard, and that they are part of the change.

Addressing the Right Problems

Change managers must be able to identify the root cause of problems and develop effective solutions. They must be able to anticipate and plan for potential obstacles that may arise during the change process, and they must be able to think critically and creatively to overcome them.

For example, when the LEGO Group was facing financial trouble in the early 2000s, they hired a new CEO, Jørgen Vig Knudstorp, who was able to identify the root cause of the problem and develop a solution. He recognized that LEGO had expanded into too many different markets and product lines, and that it had lost focus on its core business. Knudstorp developed a new strategy that involved streamlining the company’s operations, and he successfully turned LEGO around and put it on a path to sustained growth and success.

Problem-solving also includes being able to work with ambiguity and uncertainty. Change often comes with unknowns and change managers should be able to navigate through it while keeping a clear sense of direction.

Building Trust Through Empathy

Change managers must possess a high level of emotional intelligence to be able to understand and manage the emotions of those affected by the change. They must be able to empathize with employees, address their concerns, and build trust.

For Example when IBM was undergoing a major restructuring in the early 1990s, the company’s CEO, Lou Gerstner, was able to use his emotional intelligence to lead the change. Gerstner recognized that employees were concerned about the changes and their future with the company, so he made a point of meeting with employees in small groups, to listen to their concerns and allay their fears. He also implemented an employee engagement program, which helped to build trust and support for the changes.

Emotional intelligence also involves being able to understand and manage one’s own emotions during the process of change. Change can be stressful and change managers must be able to keep a clear mind and not let emotions cloud their judgment, decision making and communication during the process.

Adaptability

Change managers must be able to adapt to new situations and changing circumstances. To manage change effectively, they must be able to adjust their strategies and tactics as needed, and they must be able to remain calm and focused under pressure.

For example, when the global financial crisis hit in 2008, many organizations were forced to make significant changes in order to survive. Those that were successful, like Goldman Sachs, had leaders who were able to adapt to the changing circumstances and make quick decisions to address the crisis. The leadership at Goldman Sachs adapted its risk management strategy, including reducing its leverage and shifting to more conservative investments, which helped the company weather the crisis and emerge stronger.

Adaptability also involves being able to learn from the change process. Change managers should continuously evaluate and reflect on the process, in order to identify what worked well and what did not. This allows them to improve their change management skills and strategies in the future.

In conclusion, change management is a complex process that requires a variety of skills to be executed successfully. The top five skills for successful change managers are leadership, communication, problem-solving, emotional intelligence and adaptability. By possessing these skills, change managers can effectively guide their organizations through transitions and achieve their desired outcomes. Change managers must recognize the importance of continuous learning and adaptation to effectively navigate ongoing change management challenges in the future.